Call the Scores

MLS Matchweek 23

Columbus Crew v New York City FC prediction

Thu 23 Jul 2026, 00:30 UK time - ScottsMiracle-Gro Field, Columbus, OH

Columbus Crew v New York City FC

What the crowd is calling

Columbus Crew 40%Draw 40%New York City FC 20%

The crowd can't separate them, with calls split Home 40% / Draw 40% / Away 20%, with 1-1 the most called score.

Most called scorelines

  • 1-120%
  • 2-110%
  • 3-210%
  • 3-110%
  • 3-010%

Full time: Columbus Crew 1-2 New York City FC

The crowd backed Columbus Crew, finished 1-2.

Called the result

20%

Called the exact score

0%

Upset?

Yes

Last five in the MLS

Columbus Crew

  • L 2-3 v Minnesota United
  • L 0-3 v New York City FC
  • L 2-3 v New York Red Bulls
  • D 1-1 v Philadelphia Union
  • W 2-0 v Atlanta United FC

New York City FC

  • L 0-2 v DC United
  • W 3-0 v Columbus Crew
  • W 1-0 v Charlotte
  • D 1-1 v New York Red Bulls
  • L 1-2 v Nashville SC

Head to head

  • New York City FC 3-0 Columbus Crew10 May 2026

Every MLS Matchweek 23 fixture